Skip to content
Hiring & Market

What do you do when the client brief is thin?

The HireSalt team 5 min read

The client sends two lines and calls it a brief. You do the work anyway. Then the shortlist comes back with a no.

You can stop that from happening. Turn the thin brief into a clear scorecard, see what is missing, and ask the client about it before you send anyone. HireSalt does the first two steps for you. You stay in charge of the client conversation.

Why does a thin brief cost you a shortlist?

Picture a hiring manager who writes: “Need a good sales person, 3 to 5 years, strong communication.” That is an example, but you have seen it.

You search, screen, and send ten resumes. The reply says none are right. The client wanted someone from one industry, who had sold to one kind of buyer, and who could start soon. None of that was in the brief.

Nobody did anything wrong. People write briefs from memory, and the details they care about most feel too obvious to write down.

The real cost is finding out how thin the brief was after you have sent the shortlist. A restart looks bad, and it eats your week.

What can you do before the shortlist goes out?

Check the brief for what it leaves out. Then ask the client about each gap.

That sounds easy. It is hard when you are on your third role of the day. You read what is there. You miss what is not.

HireSalt does that check with you. It turns the written brief into criteria you can see. It also points at things the brief mentions that your scorecard does not cover yet. So your questions to the client are sharp. You skip the vague “can you tell me more about the role?”

How does HireSalt turn a JD into a scorecard?

It takes three steps.

  1. Create a job.
  2. Upload the job description, or paste the text.
  3. Read the scorecard HireSalt drafts for you.

The scorecard lists what the role will be scored on. It is a draft, and you can change all of it. Change a weight. Rename a criterion. Remove one. Add your own.

Two choices shape the draft before you review it:

  • Role level. A junior role and a lead role do not need the same bar. The setting reflects that.
  • Industry. Pick the kind of role you are hiring for, and the starting weights fit it. The industry weight presets help page lists them.

Want to know how each criterion is read once resumes arrive? How HireSalt scores a resume explains it.

What does the JD gap list show?

It shows items your brief mentions that your scorecard does not cover yet. It is a short list on purpose, so it is quick to read.

Here is an example. The brief says “client-facing” twice and names a tool once. Your scorecard scores neither. Both lines show up in the gap list.

You decide if each one matters. If it does, add it. If it is minor, leave it.

This changes your call with the client. You no longer ask if there is anything else they want. You say: “Your brief mentions client-facing work. How much of the role is that, and with what kind of clients?”

The client can answer that in a minute. And you have one less guess in the shortlist.

How do you add a criterion, and how do you take it back?

Use the criterion generator. Describe what you want to score in your own words. For example: “has handled vendor negotiations.” HireSalt drafts the criterion for you and adds it to the scorecard.

If the draft is not what you meant, undo it.

This helps when you are on a call. Try a criterion while the client is on the line. See how it reads. If they say it is not a priority, remove it with one click.

Want to see how well drafted criteria match real roles? Read do AI-drafted criteria match the role.

What if the JD is weak, or not written yet?

HireSalt tells you. If the brief you paste or upload is short, a notice appears. You know straight away that the scorecard is built on little. That is your cue to go back to the client, before you score a single resume.

What if the client has no JD at all, only a line in an email? Use the JD generator. Give it the basics: title, level, industry, and the points you noted on a call. It drafts a JD for you.

Send that draft to the client to correct. Clients who struggle to write a brief often find it easy to mark one up.

There is also a JD bias check. It reads the wording of your JD and flags phrases worth a second look, so you can fix them before the JD goes out. You decide what to change.

What stays with you?

The client conversation stays with you. So does the final call on every candidate. HireSalt does the reading and the sorting. You do the thinking.

  • You ask the client. The gap list tells you where to look. The client gives you the answers.
  • You shape the scorecard. HireSalt drafts it. You edit it until it matches the real brief.
  • You read the shortlist. Every score comes with a written reason. Nothing is rejected automatically. You decide.

This split suits an agency or a solo desk. HireSalt reads every resume against the same scorecard, the same way. You spend your time on the conversation that sharpens the brief.

How can you try it on one client role?

Pick a role where the brief felt thin. Pick one that came back last time.

  1. Paste the JD and read the scorecard.
  2. Open the gap list and write down the questions it raises.
  3. Send those questions to the client before you upload any resumes.
  4. Score a small batch, and read the written reasons.

If the answers change the brief, you have just avoided a restart.

You get 50 credits on sign-up, no card needed. That is enough to score one real role and see it for yourself. When you are ready for more, packs and plans are on the pricing page. The creating your first job help page walks you through setup, screen by screen.

Keep reading